Skip to content

Cart

Your cart is empty

Island Enchantments Academy

Module 1 · Foundations · Free

Liquid Soap and Bar Soap: What Changes

You already make bar soap. Liquid soap uses the same chemistry and the same lye calculation, but it is a different product in almost every practical way: a different alkali, a narrower recipe window, a cooked paste instead of a poured bar, a dilution step, and, above all, a finished product that is mostly water. This module shows you what changes, what stays exactly the same, and what this course leaves out, so you can decide whether liquid soap suits your plans before you buy anything.

This module builds on the Cold Process Soapmaking Course, Modules 1 and 5, and the Hot Process Soapmaking course, Module 1. It is free, together with Module 2, the safety module.

What you'll learn

  • LO1.1 Explain why liquid soap is made with potassium hydroxide and why diluted bar soap does not stay a stable liquid.
  • LO1.2 Describe the two stages of liquid soap, paste and dilution, and how their soap content differs.
  • LO1.3 Compare liquid and bar soap for alkali, purity, superfat window, water, cook, completion checks, preservation, packaging and net quantity.
  • LO1.4 Identify what carries over unchanged from the Cold Process Soapmaking Course: the lye calculation method, the 1% superfat floor, the safety rules, the discard rules and the regulatory duties.
  • LO1.5 Explain why liquid soap is not automatically milder, and decide whether liquid soap suits the learner's plans.

Why potassium hydroxide

Bar soap is made with sodium hydroxide (NaOH). Liquid soap is made with potassium hydroxide (KOH). One soapmaking educator puts it simply: KOH must be the main alkali if you want a soap that can be diluted to a stable, pourable liquid, just as NaOH must be the main alkali for a good bar [S15].

Why the difference? The same educator explains that sodium soaps tend to organise themselves into firm structures, which is why they make solid bars or ropy gels, and give up that order only when there is a great deal of water. Potassium soaps are less orderly at any water content, so they can range from a soft paste to a smooth syrup to a water-thin liquid depending on how much water and which fatty acids they contain [S17].

That is also why the shortcut many people try first does not work well. Adding water to grated bar soap gives something pourable, but experienced makers have found that its thickness does not stay stable and its texture can become unpleasant within a week or two [S15]. Real liquid soap starts with KOH.

Two stages: paste, then dilution

Liquid soap is made in two stages:

  1. The paste. Oils and a KOH solution are brought to trace and cooked, much as in hot process soap, until saponification is complete. The result is a thick, sticky, concentrated potassium soap.
  2. The dilution. The paste is dissolved in water until it reaches the thickness you want.

The soap content changes enormously between them. One educator estimates bar soap and liquid soap paste at very roughly 70–90% pure soap by weight, and diluted liquid soap at roughly 20–40% [S18]. ("Pure soap" means the weight of the oils and alkali that became soap, not counting water or additives.) In this course's running example, the paste is 65.7% pure soap after the cook and the diluted soap 25% (Module 7).

It also changes how much product you end up with. A bar recipe of 500 g of oils makes a loaf of bars weighing no more than the oils, lye and water that went into it. In this course's running example, the same 500 g of oils becomes about 935 g of paste and then about 2,455 g of diluted soap, nearly five times the weight of the oils (Modules 5 and 7). That is why one educator suggests only 100–300 g of fat for a first liquid batch [S15], why the dilution pot is the biggest piece of equipment you will buy (Module 3), and why it is worth diluting only the paste you need and keeping the rest as paste, which stores better (Modules 7 and 9). Thinking in terms of the finished, diluted product from the start also helps with fragrance, preservative and labelling, all of which are calculated on the product the user receives.

That drop in soap content is the single most important difference between bar and liquid soap. It is why diluted liquid soap can grow microbes, why it needs a preservative and a laboratory challenge test before it can leave your household, and why its packaging matters (Module 9).

Side by side

Bar soap (cold or hot process) Liquid soap
Alkali Sodium hydroxide Potassium hydroxide [S15]
Alkali purity High; a small correction or none Never pure, commonly 85–95% [S17]; a safety number (Module 4)
Alkali weight for the same oils NaOH figure About 1.403 × the NaOH figure [S17][S25]
Superfat Several percent is common 1–3% only (house rule); more clouds and separates [S17]
Water Lye concentration chosen for the bar 25–33% lye concentration (house rule) [S17]
Process Mould and cure (cold), or cook then mould (hot) Cook to a paste, then dilute (Modules 5 and 7)
Completion Cure and checks Completion protocol, never a zap test (Module 6)
Finished product A solid bar A liquid that is mostly water [S18]
Microbes A bar dries between uses Diluted soap can grow microbes; preservative and challenge test before it leaves home (Module 9)
Packaging Wrap or box New closed pump, airless or squeeze containers (Module 9)
Net quantity By weight (grams) By volume (millilitres) for liquids and viscous products [S34]

The shop calculator handles this for you: it covers liquid soap with paste dilution, lets you choose "KOH (liquid)", and uses the 1.403 ratio [S1]. Module 4 shows you how to check it by hand and how to set the purity.

What does not change

Everything you learned about lye safety and good practice in the Cold Process Soapmaking Course still applies:

  • The lye calculation method: SAP values, superfat, a calculator checked by hand (Module 4).
  • The 1% superfat floor: never below 1%, never a lye excess.
  • Protective equipment and first aid: goggles, gloves, long sleeves; lye into water; flush for 60 minutes (Module 2). KOH causes severe skin burns and eye damage [S2] and is somewhat more corrosive than sodium hydroxide [S4].
  • The discard rules: no reuse of failed or lye-heavy batches, no home neutralising of leftover lye.
  • No zap test, ever.
  • The duties of a seller: labels, notifications, accurate claims (Module 11), plus the extra rules for liquid soap.

What this course leaves out, and why

To keep the course safe and focused, some things are deliberately out of scope:

  • Neutralising with borax, boric acid or acid, and recipes with a lye excess (Module 8 explains why).
  • Cream soap, dual-lye (NaOH plus KOH) soap, shave soap and transparent alcohol soap. One educator does not recommend adding NaOH to thicken liquid soap because its behaviour is unpredictable [S17].
  • Synthetic-detergent blends (such as cocamidopropyl betaine). They can thicken liquid soap [S16] but need their own safety data.
  • Household cleaners for sale (dish, laundry or surface soaps). A product represented for those uses is not a cosmetic and falls under rules this course does not teach (Module 11).
  • Antibacterial, antiseptic or sanitising products and claims. Whether a product is a cosmetic or a drug depends mainly on how it is represented [S32]; germ-killing claims are drug territory (Module 11).
  • Microwave, pressure cooker, sous vide, direct-burner and open-flame cooking. Only the three taught cook methods.

Is liquid soap for you?

One educator does not recommend starting soapmaking with liquid soap, and suggests making bar soap first and coming back to liquid soap once your general skills are honed [S15]. This course assumes you already make cold process soap safely and can calculate lye by hand. Hot process experience helps a great deal, because the cook is a hot process cook.

Ask yourself:

  1. Can I stay with a cook for about three hours, and with a dilution for several more, with children and pets out of the room? (Course planning estimate; Module 5.)
  2. Do I have, or will I buy, stainless steel vessels big enough for the half-full rule (a dilution pot of about 5.5 L for the course's 500 g batch), a probe thermometer, and, if any soap will leave my home, a calibrated pH meter? (Module 3.)
  3. Am I happy to keep liquid soap for my own household unless and until I have a documented preservative and a passed laboratory challenge test? (Module 9.)
  4. Can I buy KOH whose supplier states its purity? (Module 4.)

If the answers are yes, liquid soap is a rewarding craft: a small batch of oils becomes a lot of soap, and most faults are about looks, not safety, provided the recipe and the record are right.

How this course is organised

Section Modules What you will do
Foundations (free) 1, 2 Understand liquid soap; pass the safety gate at 100%
Recipe and equipment 3, 4 Set up stainless vessels and measuring tools; design a recipe (Assignment 1)
Making the paste 5, 6 Cook the paste; judge completion without a zap test (Assignment 2 starts)
Dilution and finishing 7, 8, 9 Dilute, thicken, scent; preserve and package (Assignment 2 ends)
Fixing and selling 10, 11 Troubleshoot (Assignment 3); records, labels and claims (Assignment 4)

Each module has a quiz; Module 2's is a safety gate you must pass at 100% before the rest of the course opens. Each section ends with a test, and the course ends with a final examination. The assignments are self-assessed with checklists and model answers.

Scenario: putting it together

Gemma, a fictional maker, has made cold process bars for two years. She wants to make a liquid hand soap to give her sister. She plans to grate a bar into hot water, add some lavender oil and pour it into a pretty glass bottle. What would you tell her?

Grated bar soap in water does not stay a stable liquid [S15]; real liquid soap is made with KOH as a cooked paste, then diluted. The finished soap is mostly water and can grow microbes [S18], so under this course's rules it stays in her household unless it has a documented preservative and a passed challenge test, and it goes into a new closed pump bottle, never a glass or drink-style bottle (Modules 2 and 9). If she still wants to try, Module 2 comes first, and its gate must be passed before Module 3.

Key terms

  • Potassium hydroxide (KOH): the alkali for liquid soap [S15].
  • Paste: the thick, cooked, concentrated potassium soap.
  • Dilution: dissolving paste in water to a pourable soap.
  • Pure soap: the weight of oils plus alkali that became soap [S18].
  • 1.403: the KOH:NaOH weight ratio for the same oils [S17][S25].

Summary

Liquid soap is made with potassium hydroxide, because potassium soaps stay fluid across water contents while sodium soaps organise into firm structures; diluted bar soap does not stay stable [S15][S17]. It is made in two stages, a cooked paste of roughly 70–90% pure soap and a diluted soap of roughly 20–40% [S18], and that drop in soap content is why preservation and packaging matter. KOH weighs about 1.403 times the NaOH figure for the same oils [S17][S25], is never pure [S17], and is somewhat more corrosive than NaOH [S4]. The superfat window is 1–3% and the lye concentration 25–33% [S17]; net quantity is in millilitres [S34]; and liquid soap is no milder than bar soap, at about pH 9.5–11.5 [S24]. Everything else from the Cold Process Soapmaking Course, from the lye rules to the discard rules and no zap test, carries over unchanged.

© 2026 Island Enchantments. For your personal learning only; do not copy or share (Academy Terms, section A8). General information, not legal, medical or other expert advice. Information current as of 2026-11-11; check official sources before relying on it. In an emergency call 9-1-1. Poison centre: anywhere in Canada 1-844-764-7669 (1-844 POISON-X); BC 1-800-567-8911; Québec 1-800-463-5060.

Sources cited

  • S1 Island Enchantments Soap Calculator, live page text read only: covers "liquid soap with paste dilution"; lye types "NaOH (bar)", "KOH (liquid)", "Both (cream)"; purity field with the note "Purity is printed on the lye container. Most KOH is sold at about 90%"; classic recipe "Liquid soap paste"; oil table SAP values as g KOH per g oil; 1.403 KOH:NaOH ratio.
    Tier B · Island Enchantments · retrieved 2026-11-11
    https://islandenchantments.com/pages/soap-calculator
  • S2 ICSC 0357 Potassium hydroxide (May 2010): white hygroscopic solid; contact with moisture or water may generate enough heat to ignite combustible materials; the solution is a strong base, reacts violently with acid, corrosive to aluminium, tin, lead and zinc producing hydrogen; very corrosive to eyes, skin and respiratory tract; GHS Danger, harmful if swallowed, causes severe skin burns and eye damage, may cause respiratory irritation; never pour water into it, add it slowly to water; skin: remove clothes, rinse at least 15 minutes, medical attention; ingestion: rinse mouth, do not induce vomiting; storage separated from food, strong acids and metals, original container, dry, well closed; prevent dispersion of dust.
    Tier A · International Labour Organization and World Health Organization · retrieved 2026-11-11
    https://chemicalsafety.ilo.org/dyn/icsc/showcard.display?p_card_id=0357&p_version=2&p_lang=en
  • S4 Laboratory Chemical Safety Summary: Sodium Hydroxide and Potassium Hydroxide (Prudent Practices in the Laboratory, NRC, 1995): KOH "somewhat more corrosive" than NaOH; hydroxide burns may not be immediately painful while penetration continues; dilute solutions also injure skin; severe eye damage, possibly blindness; dissolving in water highly exothermic, add caustics slowly to water with stirring, never add small amounts of water to the solid; solids absorb moisture and carbon dioxide from the air; splash goggles and impermeable gloves at all times; store cool, dry, separated from acids; eye irrigation at least 15 minutes.
    Tier A · U.S. National Research Council (hosted by Stanford Environmental Health and Safety) · retrieved 2026-11-11
    https://web.stanford.edu/dept/EHS/cgi-bin/lcst/lcss/lcss80.html
  • S15 Liquid soap: Tips for making: KOH must be the main alkali for a stable pourable liquid soap; diluted bar soap's viscosity is not stable; not a first soap, learn bar soap first; 1–3% superfat; avoid recipes that need neutralising with citric acid, borax or boric acid; neutralising unnecessary with a positive superfat; dissolve KOH in room-temperature water, not hot glycerin; glycerin optional, replace with an equal weight of water; heat batter to 70–85 °C (160–180 °F) to reach trace; small batches of 100–300 g fat; most liquid soap fully saponified within about two hours, often one; covered paste can sit; store paste in a closed jar; fragrance in the finished product at 0.5–1% to start, tested on a sample.
    Tier B · Classic Bells Ltd ("Soapy Stuff") · retrieved 2026-11-11
    https://classicbells.com/soap/liquidSoapMaking.asp
  • S16 Liquid soap: Tips for diluting and thickening: honey-thick, foamer and dilute-then-thicken methods; about 50% oleic acid for thickening; far above 50% may revert to jelly; dilute with water only, never honey, aloe, milk, beer or liquids with sugars, starches or proteins; distilled or RO water preferred; judge thickness at room temperature; gradual dilution 1 part water to 2 parts paste then smaller additions; honey-thick about 30–40% pure soap, foamer about 10%, dilute-then-thicken from 15–20%; salt cuts lather and clarity and works in a narrow range; borax and sodium bicarbonate can make soap decompose and separate; no magnesium or Dead Sea salts; salt usually 0.2–2% by a salt curve in 0.2% steps on a 50–100 g sample, wait about an hour; grated NaOH bar soap 2–3%; formulas: pure soap = fat + KOH weights, pure soap % of paste, dilution water = pure soap × 100 ÷ target % − paste weight.
    Tier B · Classic Bells Ltd · retrieved 2026-11-11
    https://classicbells.com/soap/liquidSoapDiluting.asp
  • S17 Liquid soap: Tips for designing good recipes: KOH weight is not the NaOH weight (1.403); commercial KOH 85–95% pure, assume about 90% if unknown; a calculator left at 100% hides a superfat; shortcut "adjusted superfat = desired − (100 − purity)"; 25% lye concentration common (3:1), 33% gives a firmer paste, below 20% makes trace harder; superfat no more than 3% because excess fat clouds and separates; palmitic, stearic and unsaponifiables cloud; castor 10–30% for clarity; oleic about 50%; no sugary, starchy or protein additives; self-preserving effect weakens with dilution; many preservatives fail at high pH; pump or squeeze packaging; dual lye not recommended for thickening.
    Tier B · Classic Bells Ltd · retrieved 2026-11-11
    https://classicbells.com/soap/liquidSoapRecipes.asp
  • S18 Should you add preservative to liquid soap?: most makers do not preserve paste; less agreement on diluted soap; very few preservatives work at soap's high pH, the author knows only three (Suttocide A, Glydant Plus, Liquid Germall Plus, the last off-label); microbes migrate in liquid and growth often starts at container edges, lid, dip tube and pump; diluted soap roughly 20–40% pure soap against 70–90% for bars and paste; a preservative is insurance, not a substitute for sanitation; pump or squeeze bottles rather than open jars; challenge testing by a laboratory; the author does not sell products that need preservation; small batches, refrigerate, watch for changes.
    Tier B · Classic Bells Ltd · retrieved 2026-11-11
    https://classicbells.com/soap/liquidSoapPreservative.asp
  • S24 Soap pH: cheap paper strips often read 2–3 units low; test at room temperature in a 1–10% pure-soap solution in distilled water; paste and diluted liquid soap are too concentrated to read accurately; pH alone cannot detect lye excess (a few tenths of a unit); properly made soap about pH 9.5–11.5 depending on fatty acids; pure oleate about 11.2, laurate 10.1, palmitate 10.7; acid decomposes soap into fatty acids, much of it no longer soap by the time pH falls 1–1.5 units.
    Tier B · Classic Bells Ltd · retrieved 2026-11-11
    https://classicbells.com/soap/pH.asp
  • S25 Dual lye recipe: the KOH molecule is 1.403 times the weight of NaOH; dual lye used for cream, shave and some liquid soaps.
    Tier B · Classic Bells Ltd · retrieved 2026-11-12
    https://classicbells.com/soap/dualLye.asp
  • S32 Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the Cosmetic-Drug Interface: definitions of cosmetic and drug (Food and Drugs Act s. 2); representation (claims, explicit or implied, by words, pictures or symbols) is the key consideration, with composition and mode of action.
    Tier A · Health Canada · retrieved 2026-11-11
    https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/consumer-product-safety/reports-publications/industry-professionals/guidance-document-classification-products-cosmetic-drug-interface.html
  • S34 Industry Guide for the labelling of cosmetics: net quantity declared by volume for a liquid, gas or viscous substance and by weight for a solid; net quantity and product identity in English and French on the principal display panel; Schedule names ("Aqua" or "Water/Eau"); rinse-off product definition; fragrance allergens disclosed above 0.01% in rinse-off and 0.001% in leave-on products, List 1 from 2026-04-12, List 2 from 2026-08-01 (new) and 2028-08-01 (existing). s. 8.3.8.1 (naming of grouped allergens): the group name given for a grouped entry must be used in the list of ingredients, required when the sum of the entry's substances exceeds 0.01% rinse-off or 0.001% leave-on; listing the individual substances as well is permitted, not mandatory. Appendix 1 List 2 names whole essential oils, e.g. Lavandula Angustifolia (Lavender) Oil and the lavandin oils ("Lavandula Oil/Extract" shall be indicated), the orange peel oils ("Citrus Aurantium Peel Oil"), Eucalyptus Globulus Leaf Oil ("Eucalyptus Globulus Oil"); re-read 2026-11-12.
    Tier A · Health Canada · retrieved 2026-11-11
    https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/consumer-product-safety/reports-publications/industry-professionals/labelling-cosmetics.html

Module quiz

10 questions drawn at random from a bank of 25. Pass mark 80%. Retake as often as you like.

Progress is saved in this browser.

The Island Enchantments Academy offers self-paced courses for personal and small-business learning. It is not a certified or registered private training institution under British Columbia's Private Training Act. Its courses are not accredited and do not lead to a diploma, degree or professional licence.

Courses created by Fernquill Studio for Island Enchantments

Island Enchantments · Victoria, BC · islandenchantments.com