You already make cold process soap. Hot process uses the same oils, the same lye, the same calculation and the same safety rules. The difference is what happens after trace: instead of pouring the batter into a mould and letting the reaction finish there, you keep it hot in a pot until the reaction has finished, and then mould it. That one change affects the water, the texture, the timing of fragrance and superfat, the design possibilities, the hazards and the records. This module sets out what changes and what does not, so you can decide whether hot process is for you before you buy anything.
The course assumes you have done the Cold Process Soapmaking Course, especially Modules 1, 2, 5, 6, 9, 14 and 15. It is strongly recommended, though not required: everything safety-critical is restated here, and Module 2 of this course is a safety gate you must pass at 100%.
What you'll learn
- LO1.1 Explain hot process as the cold process reaction with heat applied after trace so that saponification finishes in the pot before moulding.
- LO1.2 Compare hot and cold process for timing of saponification, water, texture, design, fragrance and superfat timing, cure and records.
- LO1.3 Identify what carries over unchanged from the Cold Process Soapmaking Course: the lye calculation, the 1% superfat floor, the safety rules, the discard rules and the regulatory duties.
- LO1.4 Explain why cooked soap is not automatically milder or safe to use, and why this course never uses the zap test.
- LO1.5 Decide when hot process suits a product and when cold process is the better choice.
The same reaction, with heat after trace
Saponification is the reaction between oils and sodium hydroxide that makes soap and glycerin; the Cold Process Soapmaking Course, Module 1, explains it. Kevin Dunn's soap research, published on a supplier's blog, makes the point that "hot" and "cold" process differ by technique rather than by temperature: in hot process, heat is applied to the mixture after the oils and lye are combined, typically until the soap reaches gel and the reaction is complete; in cold process, no outside heat is applied after mixing, and most of the reaction happens in the mould [S29].
Heat speeds the reaction a great deal. In Dunn's measurements on a four-oil soap at 33% lye with no lye discount, held at a constant temperature, saponification was complete after a little more than an hour at 70 °C (158 °F) and after two hours at 60 °C (140 °F), while at 50 °C (122 °F) the soap was still alkaline well beyond four hours [S28]. Supplier tutorials hold the soap at or above about 71 °C (160 °F) by slow cooker or oven to speed the reaction up [S30][S31].
Those measurements were made on one recipe, held at a steady temperature; a real hot process batch is wetter, rises and falls in temperature, and loses water. They show the direction, not a cook time for your batch. Module 6 turns them into the course's completion protocol.
Side by side
| Cold process | Hot process | |
|---|---|---|
| Where saponification finishes | Mostly in the mould, over a day or two [S38] | In the pot, before moulding [S29] |
| Water | Course window 28–40% lye concentration (Cold Process Soapmaking Course) | Often about 25% (3 : 1 water to lye) to allow for evaporation [S36]; this course uses 25–33% |
| Texture in the mould | Smooth, pourable batter | Thick and rustic, like mashed potatoes [S30][S31] |
| Design | Fine swirls and very fluid designs | Glopped layers, spoon swirls; fluid hot process allows simple swirls but not cold process detail [S34] |
| Fragrance | Added to the batter before or at trace | Added after the cook [S30][S32][S33]; in this course only below its flash point (HR-3) |
| Superfat | Lye discount | Lye discount, after-cook oil, or both; the course uses both (Module 4) |
| Cure | At least 4 weeks and a steady weight (Cold Process Soapmaking Course) | Sources range from "use right away" to 6 weeks [S30][S31][S32][S34][S38]; this course: steady weight and at least 4 weeks |
| Records | Batch Log | Cook Log: the Batch Log plus temperatures, completion checks and after-cook additions (Module 6) |
| Extra hazards | Lye, raw batter | Lye, raw batter, plus hot caustic batter, steam, boil-overs and appliances (Module 2) |
What does not change
- The lye calculation. Each oil needs the same lye whether you cook it or not; the shop calculator works it out from SAP values and the 1.403 KOH-to-NaOH ratio [S1].
- The 1% superfat floor. The calculator calls superfat your safety margin and says to keep it above 1% [S1]. The course's house rules discard any batch whose recorded superfat is below 1%.
- Protective equipment, lye handling and first aid. Goggles, gloves and long sleeves; lye into cold water; flush skin and eyes for at least 60 minutes and get to hospital [S2]. Module 2 restates every rule.
- The discard rules. No reuse of failed or lye-heavy batches; discard at pH 11 or more on the lather or a recorded superfat below 1% (house rules).
- The regulatory duties. Hot process soap is a cosmetic like any other: the Cosmetic Regulations' labelling and notification rules apply in full [S53]. Module 11 covers what hot process changes.
"Cooked" is not "milder", and not automatically safe
Two beliefs about hot process soap are common online. Neither holds up.
"Hot process soap is gentler." A double-blind study of 41 adults compared natural soaps made by cold and by hot process and found that both raised the skin's surface pH immediately, with the rise lasting up to 30 minutes [S47]. The method does not make soap gentle. This course never presents "hot process" as a skin benefit (the course's cautious interpretation, Module 11).
"Once it's cooked, it's safe." Only if the cook really finished, and the recipe was right in the first place. At trace, about 90–95% of the lye is still unreacted in Dunn's measurements [S28]. An undercooked batch, or a batch with a weighing error, still holds free lye, and a batch can look finished at the edges while the centre is not (Module 6). Sodium hydroxide burns skin and eyes [S2].
When to choose hot process, and when not
Hot process suits:
- Fragrances that misbehave in cold process. Some fragrances accelerate, seize or separate cold process batter [S40]; one supplier notes that fragrance oils that sometimes seize cold process soap will generally work in hot process, because they go in after the cook [S33].
- Rustic designs: chunky textures, glopped layers, textured tops [S30][S31].
- Unmoulding sooner. Supplier tutorials unmould and cut after 1–2 days [S30][S32]. This does not mean selling sooner: the course's release rule is the same four weeks and steady weight as cold process (Module 9).
- Rescuing a seized or separated cold process batch within 24 hours, when the weights are verified correct (Module 10, house rule HR-8) [S40].
Cold process is better for:
- fine swirls, thin pour techniques and anything that needs a long time at a thin trace [S34];
- a smooth, glossy top;
- makers who cannot give a batch two to three hours of uninterrupted attention (the cook must be attended from start to finish, house rule HR-4).
A quick self-check before you start
Answer these honestly before you buy anything for hot process:
- Can you make a correctly weighed, correctly calculated cold process batch, and recalculate its superfat from actual weights?
- Can you keep children and pets out of the room for two to three hours at a time?
- Will you stay beside a hot cooker for the whole cook, and switch it off for every interruption?
- Do you have, or will you buy, a stainless steel vessel big enough that your batch fills half or less, and a probe thermometer you can check in ice water?
- Will you wait at least four weeks and a steady weight before using or selling the bars?
If any answer is no, start with the Cold Process Soapmaking Course or solve that point first. Module 2 of this course, which is free, sets out every hazard the cook adds.
What this course does not cover
- Liquid (potassium hydroxide) soap. It is cooked too, but it is a different product with its own calculations and dilution; it belongs to a separate Liquid Soap course.
- Rebatching and hand-milling as product methods. These melt finished soap and reshape it; they are not hot process. Rebatching a lye-heavy batch is never allowed (house rule).
- Cook methods other than the slow cooker, oven and double boiler. No microwave, pressure cooker, sous vide bag, direct burner or open flame (house rule HR-9, Module 5).
- Dairy in hot process. Some tutorials stir in dairy such as yogurt after the cook [S34]; this course leaves dairy out of all formulas and projects (Module 7 explains why).
- New regulatory teaching. The full rules are in the Cold Process Soapmaking Course, Modules 16–19, and Selling Handmade Cosmetics in Canada; Module 11 covers what hot process changes.
The course at a glance
| Section | Modules |
|---|---|
| Foundations (free) | 1 What changes · 2 Lye, heat and steam safety (safety gate) |
| Recipe and equipment | 3 Equipment and set-ups · 4 Formulating for hot process |
| The cook | 5 Cook methods · 6 Cook stages and judging completion |
| Finishing | 7 After the cook · 8 Smoother texture · 9 Moulding, cutting and curing |
| Fixing and selling | 10 Troubleshooting · 11 Records, labelling and selling |
Four self-assessed assignments (a recipe conversion, a cook log, a troubleshooting case file and a label check) and a final exam complete the course. The Certificate of Completion from Island Enchantments recognises that you finished the course; it is not a licence or a government approval.
Scenario: is hot process for Ruth?
Ruth makes cold process soap for a weekend craft table. Her favourite fragrance, a spicy blend, seizes in cold process every time, and her customers like rustic, chunky bars. She has a busy household and often gets interrupted. She hoped hot process would let her sell soap the week she made it.
Hot process suits her fragrance and her style: the fragrance goes in after the cook, below its flash point, and rustic texture is natural [S30][S33]. But two things need planning. She will need a two-to-three-hour window with the house quiet, because the cook is attended from start to finish and children and pets stay out of the room (Module 2). And under the course's release rule, she still cures for at least four weeks to a steady weight before selling (Module 9).
Key terms
- Hot process: soapmaking in which heat is applied after trace so saponification finishes in the pot, before moulding [S29].
- Cold process: soapmaking in which no outside heat is applied after mixing and most of the reaction happens in the mould [S29].
- Cook: the period of applied heat after trace, until the completion protocol passes.
- Completion protocol: the course's four checks for judging that the cook is finished, with no zap test (Module 6).
- After-cook addition: anything added once the cook is complete, such as superfat oil, colour and fragrance.
- House rule: a course rule stricter than at least one published source (Module 2).
Summary
Hot process is cold process with heat applied after trace so the reaction finishes in the pot [S29]; heat speeds saponification strongly [S28]. It usually needs more water (about 25% lye concentration [S36]; 25–33% in this course), gives a rustic texture [S30][S31], suits fragrances that misbehave in cold process [S33][S40], and adds fragrance and superfat oil after the cook. The lye calculation, the 1% floor [S1], the safety rules [S2], the discard rules and the regulatory duties [S53] do not change. Cooked soap is not automatically milder [S47] or safe: an incomplete cook leaves free lye [S28], so this course never uses the zap test and judges completion by its protocol. Cure is to a steady weight and at least four weeks, as for cold process.